The City and the Pillar: An actual review
Ah, to be alive in the '50s: the wonders of the new interstate highway system, the convenience of modern appliances, the crippling need to conform. Sure, being a rebel without a cause was cool, but there were limits. Certain cultural "inversions" were either never discussed or dismissed with a sneer. The 1948 New York Times review of Gore Vidal's novel, The City and the Pillar, rejected the work, calling it a "case history of the standard homosexual," and further insulted it by flying over the major plot points at a cruising altitude of 35,000 feet. There is much more to this novel than The New York Times reviewer would admit.
The literary stereotypes for gay characters until that time relegated them to a few categories: Exceedingly effeminate, transvestites, or studious outcasts who married but harbored a secret desire. In order to challenge the prevailing stereotypes, Vidal's main character, Jim Willard, is purposefully their opposite. He is masculine. He is an athlete. He is in love with his best friend, Bob Ford, also an All-American man's man. Their first sexual encounter takes place on a camping trip just before Bob graduates from high school and takes to the sea.
"Two bodies faced one another where only an instant before a universe had lived; the star burst and dwindled, spiraling them both down to the meager, to the separate, to the night and the trees and the firelight; all so much less than what had been."
This is the only instance of anything approaching poetry in the whole of the novel. Jim's first experience with Bob turns out to be the only sexual experience that leaves an indelible mark. His subsequent encounters pale in comparison. Vidal conveys this stark reality through dispassionate prose describing the years of Jim's life without Bob. The intervening sexual experiences are never mentioned in any detail, merely implied. Besides his later partners, Ronald Shaw and Paul Sullivan, the others are faceless and innumerable. These men are only placeholders, time-killers, until Jim reunites with Bob.
After stints as a cabin boy, tennis instructor, and Air Corps physical fitness trainer, Jim returns home to Virginia and learns that Bob has returned home as well — with his wife. The two men meet and speak of old times. The real reunion happens later, in a hotel room in New York. It is far from the magical experience Jim built up in his mind during their years apart. In the 1948 version of The City and the Pillar, Jim kills Bob after their failed sexual encounter. Vidal rewrote the ending in 1965, softening Jim's retribution, though it is no less violent.
Besides the tryst by the river, Vidal siphoned off all emotion and sentiment from the rest of the novel. I didn't care about any of the characters because they all seemed devoid of any human spark. They trudged through the motions, stiff-armed like Dawn of the Dead extras.
Drawbacks aside, reading this book was well worth the effort. The City and the Pillar was ground-breaking for its time, and Gore Vidal was infinitely brave for writing the novel and publishing it rather than shoving it to the back of a desk drawer in hopes of a less repressive environment than America in the 1950s.
Rating: 3 of 5
4 comments
An actual review after 60 years! Better late than never. I thought this was a good/offbeat choice of book to examine.
Jean Forst
Hey Lindy—
Didn’t know about this book—weird that NYT would represent it like that. Nice work—I enjoy your selections, and the way you review them. Great wit!
The NYT actually refused to review any of Vidal’s work for 6 years after TCTP. He was essentially blacklisted from print publicity. Good thing he didn’t let it get him down.
Jean Forst
Yikes! Backlash can be a really scary, powerful thing.
Most Recent Arts Comments
Local, I forgot to offer you a piece of sage advice. Don’t bag on 39 south because they represent your potential collector pool. Even though I haven’t lived in Champaign since 1997, 39 south is still the only arts entity that has promoted my work as an…
Lest 39 South feels picked on: Check this from the Urbana City Public Arts Program: “Calling all Champaign County Artists! We’re pleased to announce a Call for Entries for a new initiative called Murals on Glass, which will feature artwork reproduced in adhesive vinyl displayed on the…
You forgot Jonathon Fineberg was also personal pals with the Christo’s. I’ll agree that Dr. Fineberg has done a tremendous job communicating to undergrads why this stuff is important, but I won’t kiss the ring because he also contributed to the dismantling of crafts at the U…
And boom goes the dynamite.
I think the best and most exciting arts programming in Champaign-Urbana is at the Krannert Art Museum. The depth and quality of the museum’s permanent collection speaks highly to the intelligence of the art history faculty at the University. I have to say taking Art History with…
Another mystifying thing is 39 South touts the fact that when you consider all things that are considered “art”, i.e. music, exhibits, movies, performances, craft fairs, circuses, ect; art in Champaign County apparently generates $60 million dollars of “economic activity” every year, so says 39 South. And…
I have to agree, I’m a bit confused as to the purpose of 40 North, although I am aware that the organization is in a period of restructuring and re-examination. And yes, the “staff of 1” does work tirelessly to keep the operations afloat, but the fact…
“Making art accessible to everyone and cultivating the art and artists in Champaign County is 40 North’s main mission.” FACT: When the Urbana City Council proposed to form a new public arts council of its own in 2008, 39 South actually sent letters from board members Cody…
On behalf of the New Art Film Festival, I’d like to thank you for highlighting our event in this article. It is our pleasure to put together this showcase for the community and the recognition is highly appreciated by all of us involved in the NAFF. Also,…
Most Popular Arts Articles (60 days)
- New film showcases the wonders of the Linotype machine
- The intricate jest of Rob Delaney
- Spotlight: Drag shows in Champaign-Urbana, Part IV
- Behind the Scenes of Cirque du Soleil: Quidam at Assembly Hall
- No foolin’, April is gonna be good
- An interview with Maya Bruck of Pixo
- Crispin Hellion Glover does it all
- Weiskamp makes poster printing a community experience
- Mark Neely returns to C-U for S&B
- Amelia Gray to close out the Carr series
Most Recent Comments
Dollars to waffles says the study session will conclude that there is parking available in the Hill Street Parking Deck.
I can see requiring them to plug meters where they park, but the license fee thing sure sounds like some established business doesn’t like the competition and has an in with the city gummint staff.
As a teenager too broke to actually buy anything, I indulged in many a free cup of Kopi water.
This is pretty much ridiculous. However, I would hope that local businesses that aren’t opposed would step up and allow the Crave Truck in their private parking lots. That won’t solve the licensing issue though… (Insert not-so-subtle reference to Snell being behind the grand conspiracy to kill…
Excellent additions, LY.
Possible Honorary Categories: Most Bizarre Restaurant Decor: Mas Amigos on Springfield Av. With painstaking attention to shelving, the owner proudly displays his NFL football helmet collection. WTF? Best Pancakes: Courier Cafe. Huge, fluffy, served with hot syrup. If you can stuff 3 of these down, you don’t…
@Jason: You’re right about that. I get groceries at Schnucks (they carry what I buy, which I can’t say of any other single grocery store in town), and if they have a beer I’m in the market for it’s usually a quarter or two cheaper per 6-…
Best Neighborhood Bar (& Grill) : Urbana - My ‘hood- the ‘Boom! http://www.boomerangbarandgrill.com Go on a Wing Wednesday or Fish Friday, or see a band play some night. Local blue-collar Urbana terroir galore. My only beer snobbish gripe is lack of a pale hopped ale, but you…
That article almost looks like something out of The Onion
Thanks! I’m looking forward to writing even more….
The one thing that’s bothered me for a while about the Friar is that, for most commonly purchased adult beverages, you can actually walk down the strip mall to Schnucks and get them cheaper. It makes no sense, but there it is. I suspect it’s because Schnucks…
Thanks for the sage advice Mary Anna, but I’m long done with the sucking up and being thankful for the scraps. The most important thing an artist can do to live with yourself is tell the emperor he’s got no clothes, and spray paint something on his…
Local, I forgot to offer you a piece of sage advice. Don’t bag on 39 south because they represent your potential collector pool. Even though I haven’t lived in Champaign since 1997, 39 south is still the only arts entity that has promoted my work as an…
Maybe I complained enough in person. One time I even explained to the (wholly uninterested) clerk how to navigate the Illinois Statutes web page, and Savoy’s Municipal Code database I wouldn’t know because I only go there when I want to pay 30% more for anything, which is never.
Yay! Love this! Welcome to the family!
@Rob: You seem to have the weirdest experiences. I’m in Friar Tuck every other week (don’t tell my mom that I’m a lush). They never fail to ask for my birth date but never my age, they never card afterwards, and they often allow me to use…
This column affords me a long-awaited opportunity. I’ve wanted to write my own column called Fuck You Friar Tuck Liquors. but I always thought it’d be too pithy. Here, I can say Fuck You Friar Tuck Liquors and not feel bothered to stretch it out to 750…
Lest 39 South feels picked on: Check this from the Urbana City Public Arts Program: “Calling all Champaign County Artists! We’re pleased to announce a Call for Entries for a new initiative called Murals on Glass, which will feature artwork reproduced in adhesive vinyl displayed on the…
Ha! Exactly. You, sir, are welcome at the bar in My House.
Why wait ‘til 3 pm?
Most Popular Articles (14 days)
- 2012 Pygmalion Music Festival initial lineup
- “Opposite” marriage includes fun, love, and drinking in the day
- Cafe Zojo steals the show
- Triptych bypasses another hurdle, waits for results
- Groce loses first staffer
- Paradises Lost; paradigms shifted
- Weekender: May 4–6
- The Market Watch returns!
- Ashes to Ashes | Rust to Rust
- BEST Arts
Facebook
Twitter
Full Site
Thanks for the sage advice Mary Anna, but I’m long done with the sucking up and being thankful for the scraps. The most important thing an artist can do to live with yourself is tell the emperor he’s got no clothes, and spray paint something on his…